business name, category, key word, etc.
Locations region, city or postal code for better results
No recent locations
Find local businesses, rate your experiences, and share with the community
Love It Hate It
2 0
popup tail
3 stars 11 reviews

Super Mario's Pizza

« Back

281 King St
Port Colborne, ON  L3K 4H2

(905) 834-1441

Get Directions
Start from:

What the community has to say about Super Mario's Pizza

Add your review
Reviews [1]
3 star rating
WiFiWiMax Port Colborne, ON May 23, 2011
Super Marios Pizza Port Colborne solves my craving for Pizza

I found Super Mario's Pizza Port Colborne last year and have visited a few times. IF you are looking for a more formal dine-in experience, this is not the place. Having said that, there is only one other pizzeria in town and they don't have any sit down service. I first met "Super Mario" over 20 years ago when he owned and operated two other pizza shops in Niagara Falls. He sold them and purchased this place in Port. He is true blue (or should I say true green and red) Italian! You can taste Italy in every pizza pie made. He has good staff, most of them high school students that really seem to know their jobs. Most of the time I order for myself and they have always been very efficient. I have picked up an order for a family meal and the family all liked it. I've ordered everything at one time or another - pizza, chicken wings, subs and panzarroti. I don't eat pizza too often however when I'm craving for pizza or wings, Super Mario's is it AND it's now the only pizza shop that has more than just cheese and pepperoni toppings! Port Colborne is fortunate to have Super Mario bring his expertise to town!

Other Reviews from the web
3 star rating
Will not order here again
July 12, 2014

The food has went so far down hill.The pizza was very greasy ,and not cooked all the way.I use to order from here often.I cant believe how bad it is now.I will never order again.

Brought to you by tripadvisor

3 star rating
Didn't say gluten free cost a lot more
April 18, 2014

Had a vegetarian pizza. The sign said they could do gluten-free and they did! Good! But they never said it cost a lot more. Bad! To me that's false advertising that they didn't saying anything at first. They made it quite fast but they made a mistake and put meat on it that I did not ask for so they... more

Brought to you by tripadvisor

3 star rating
Best pizza and wings in town
March 23, 2014

Best pizza and wings in town I have tried other places and nothing compares to Super Mario's Pizza..

Brought to you by tripadvisor

3 star rating
awesome wings
October 09, 2013

wings, well done medium are awesome...among the best wings I have ever had and trust me I have had wings from here to Miami to California to Alaska...no joke...trucking is the way to find good food

Brought to you by tripadvisor

3 star rating
Good service, awful pizza
August 15, 2013

I ordered a large thin crust pizza with three toppings (about $15) on a Thursday at around 5. The young woman on the phone was friendly (kind of rare, with pizza joints), repeated my order correctly, and told me the delivery would be about 50 minutes; actually only took about 40 (I'm about eight blocks from the restaurant). Super Mario's... more

Brought to you by tripadvisor

3 star rating
Great Pizza
July 14, 2013

They make the best vegetarian pizza I have ever tried! Other pizzas is extremely tasty as well. Service is prompt and friendly. Recommend that you order well in advance because this place is hopping during holiday weekends, play offs etc. Well worth the wait!

Brought to you by tripadvisor

3 star rating
Not impressed
June 30, 2013

I ordered a steak sub & perogies with bacon and onion
They said it would be ready in 40 minutes.. Its been an hour & 10 minutes & they are still not here.
I called & the lady on the phone was quite rude . Saying there is only 3 of them working and they Are swamped. At least make... more

Brought to you by tripadvisor

3 star rating
Wings over Pizza
June 28, 2013

Have not been too impressed with the pizza at this establishment - the taste is boring. Missing key flavours in the sauce and the dough. We do though keep going back for the wings and will do so again!

Brought to you by tripadvisor

3 star rating
Some good pizza
June 13, 2013

Ever since I moved to port 4years ago I've always come here for my pizza. They're slices are huge and I can never finish one. Cheap prices and good food. Must try for a quick slice!!

Brought to you by tripadvisor

3 star rating
Used to be better
January 11, 2012

Used to be my place of choice, but for the past year or two the pizza has either been undercooked over overcooked - every single time. Doesn't matter if I've gotten a full pizza or a single slice.

Brought to you by tripadvisor

Business Description from the Web
August 25, 2013

This is the third pizzeria for "Super Mario" who has been making pizza for over 30 years. Super Mario's Pizza Port Colborne is a small family run business located in downtown Port Colborne. We're just one block north of Historic West Street and the Clarence Street Bridge overlooking the Welland Canal. Find us behind the old train station and two doors from Jumbo Video. We have seating for 12... more

Brought to you by tripadvisor

All Rights Reserved © 2008-2020 Weblocal.ca