I've been here 3 times in the last 8 years and each time it's a great experience.
For the price, you get a 3 course meal and an entertaining and interactive show. It's wonderful as a first date, to help break the ice, or for a night with the kids or with your friends just to get the night started. I am definitely a fan and I don't know how anyone can complain about this place, but to each their... more

Bought a groupon..overall just an OK experience... Personally prefer Second city a little bit more. Food is average. Waiter didn't pay much attention to us. Actors are very friendly though:).

I went here for my hubby's birthday with his family a while back. We purchased some Teambuy tickets for the dinner and show. The place is sizable but nothing fancy. The show was mediocre with some good laughs here and there. I liked how they encourage the audience to participate but I definitely think it could have been better executed. The chicken entree was quite good but the beef entree was... more

Came in using the company employee appreciation. We were seated in the same table as 4 other strangers which was OK for me. Just wished there were more space for my arms as I keep touching the person beside me. Food was good as I ordered the soup, fish and tira misu. The show was really good and funny. Kudos to the witty actors who can come up with a retort on the spot. I just wished there was... more

Came here for the show only - what a fun night!

Show is incredibly interactive, the actors will come around pre-show and chat with you, and may incorporate you in the show by giving you a line or two. Production is fairly small and has only a handful of actors, but is very entertaining to watch and be a part of!

The plot will change from time to time so you can certainly come back for more.... more

$30 or so for the dinner
$50 or so for the show
$80 or so for both.

the dinner was not too bad but i wouldn't say it's worth $30-35 normally. I think $20-25 would be a fair price. The show, is worth the $50 though. It was fun, interactive and entertaining. They make full use of the dining area and if you booked a reservation to celebrate something there, they will include you in part of the... more

I've been here three times now and every time is an enjoyable evening. The food looks good and has great texture. (My sense of smell is impaired, so I can't speak either way to the flavours, but that texture of the crust on the salmon. MMMMMMM!)

The actors are professional and highly entertaining. It's great to have them interacting with everyone and try to include all the birthday boys and... more

We loved the show. Great actors. Great plot. Lots of comedic lines. The food SO much better than expected. It was very good. My son John whom we call Jay won a prize for guessing whodunnit. Because we live out of town, he gave the tickets he won to a local - Billy, the stunt double. It was loads of fun.
Only challenge is the stairs for ability-challenged mom (aka me). Would DEFINITELY recommend... more

We came here for a work event and had a great time. It's a little difficult to find the place since the entry is smaller than other stores in the area. However, the inside of the dinner theater is quite large, with room for 20+ tables of 6-8. It may be difficult to find parking in the area, so I recommend using Google Street View ahead of time.

Coat check is required, but it's complimentary.... more

This was my first time at a dinner theatre, and it was surprisingly good.

Pros:
-Plot was entertaining
-Audience participation was light, and not embarrassing
-Great for family or group gatherings

Cons:
-Food was OK, nothing special

Make sure to look for discount tickets!

Fabulous and memorable night with co-workers. I was a bit dubious after reading the reviews but I must admit that the food was really good and I'm a food snob. The corn chowder was excellent and the beef with smashed potatoes succulent and tender.The actors were fab and I was quite taken that they were able to stay in character while having to deal with a diversity of patrons. Quick and clever... more

I visited this place a couple of weeks ago and it's still on my mind. Anyone who has an appreciation for theatre and comedy would definitely get a kick out of this place! It's truly a unique experience. The servers are all very kind and charismatic the drinks are creative and delicious, and the atmosphere was a mix between light-hearted and suspenseful. Perfect for a mystery show!

The show was... more

By far one of the best experiences I've had in terms of dinner/entertainment.

The staff is very good and attentive, the actors (and their characters) are extremely engaging creating the right atmosphere for a night to remember.

The food was excellent, not overwhelmingly complicated leaving the focus on the main attraction (the mystery).

A place I'll go back for sure - relax, unwind and... more

The show is quite entertaining however with a very low production value, it is a very expensive show, $40 for the show, plus $30 or $35 for dinner.

The food is horrid! You can basically cook a better meal at home.

Sorry I had to rate you guys so low. Loved the actors, you guys gave me lots of laughs, but you are extremely expensive for what you get.

Love it here! Food isn't spectacular but we didn't expect 5star either. Portions could be bigger but guess we all could serve to eat less sometimes. Shows are up to the times & make great pop culture references, which is always FUN. We used deal tickets from deal sites to visit, as they run frequently, & it was all def worth more than paying half price! These days u cant eat out at a nice place... more

Went there for my husband's Christmas dinner. Really enjoyed it as it was different experience where you get to participate in solving the mystery. All the characters were very nice and We were all laughing and the food I had was the ribs and I really liked it. It was fun and would go back again just for the fun of it.

I went to Mysteriously Yours with some friends. Overall, it was a fairly enjoyable experience, but I found the food to be pretty disappointing. The actors and the play itself were cheesy (but that was expected) and all had a good attitude and had the audience laughing often. They had mandatory coat check which wasn't the greatest as there was a line up to check and then again at the end of the... more

Rating: 3.5/5...gave it a 4 to boost up the past poor reviews.

After reading the terrible reviews that other Yelpers have written I went to Mysteriously Yours with the lowest expectations that one can expect. Parking is a bit difficult to find on a Friday night so I had to park in the residential area which is about a 5-10 minute walk but I jogged so I got there in no time.

The dinner/show is... more

As long as you're ready to enjoy some cheesiness, you will enjoy yourself. Don't be expecting to see a Broadway play or dine in a 5-star restaurant, but for what it is, a night out on the town, Mysteriously Yours is fine.....maybe a little expensive

Always fun and always funny. I have seen three shows: "Tangled Web", "Murder at Twilight", and "Apprentice to Murder". Murder at Twilight, which is inspired by current vampire movies and TV series "True Blood" is my favourite, but it might not be as good if you're not familiar with the TV show. I've only been to the Yonge Street location where I had the prix fixe menu, and found the food to be... more

The show itself is great - interactive with the audience, clever jokes, new themes every week that cater to popular culture - entertaining enough for a night out!

Where this dinner theatre loses marks are for quality of food and service. The food is mediocre, comparable to tv dinners or airplane food, but edible at least. Salad, soup and dessert were good which is less than I could say for the... more

I loved it. Such a funny show, I love trying to guess who the murderer is! The food and drinks are great (especially the desserts!) and the serving staff is charming. I love the location. Yonge and Davisville subway station. Or park on the side streets. And I went with my friend- we had a girls night out- and it was perfect! Got our minds off the kids and husbands and just laughed and treated... more

It is expensive for sure. And I won't say that it was extremely funny. Average jokes, average food. But it is a nice place to come with your girlfriend or family.
So bad there is not much competition.

I got an invite to this theatre and was pretty excited to go, I mean it's like clue... In real life!

The first thing I did when I went inside was check in. After finding the place on my phone, I saw the previous reviews and it wasn't exactly too too amazing (meh). I decided to wait to pass judgement.

The dinner/show is set up in the following fashion. Appetizers followed by the entree... more

Horrible!!!!!!!!

I've been to a few dinner theatres before and they were fun. This one is not. A friend took another friend and I there as birthday gifts for us both. If it hadn't been for not wanting him to feel worse then he already did about the fiasco, I think I would have stood up in the middle of it and made a huge scene, demanding management come out onto the floor and everyone in the... more